The following is a list of guest judges on Face Off.
Season 1[]
- Thomas Pendleton (Foundation)
- Filippo Ioco
- Michael Westmore
- Sean S. Cunningham
- Steve LaPorte (Foundation)
- Bob Jacks (Foundation)
- Greg Nicotero
Season 2[]
- Ve Neill (Foundation)
- Conor McCullagh (Foundation)
- Jennifer Aspinall (Foundation)
- Asher Roth
- Tom Savini
- Sam Huntington (Foundation)
- Vivica A. Fox
- Kim Greene (Foundation)
- Greg Cannom
- LeVar Burton
- Catherine O'Hara
- Cleve and Constance Hall
- Michael Westmore
Season 3[]
- Sean Astin (Foundation)
- Matthew Wood
- Laila Ali (Foundation)
- Paul W. S. Anderson
- Kevin Smith
- Lijha Stewart (Foundation)
- Patrick Tatopoulos (Foundation/Spotlight)
- Brian Grazer
- Gale Ann Hurd
- Richard Hatem
Season 4[]
- Michael Westmore (Foundation)
- John Rhys-Davies
- John Meyer (Foundation)
- Will Cotton
- Bryan Singer
- Lijha Stewart (Foundation)
- Gale Anne Hurd (Foundation)
- Jon Landau
Season 5[]
- Catherine Hardwicke (Foundation)
- Kevin Grevioux
- Glenn Hetrick (Foundation)
- Jordu Schell
- Valli O'Reilly (Foundation)
- Elvira (Foundation)
- Bryan Fuller
- Patrick Tatopoulos (Foundation)
Season 6[]
- Tami Lane (Foundation)
- Stephen Sommers
- Scott Charles Stewart
- Patrick Tatopoulos (Foundation/Spotlight)
- Howard Berger (Foundation)
- Doug Jones
- Kazuhiro Tsuji (Foundation/Spotlight)
- Lucy Dahl
- Valli O'Reilly
- Len Wisemen
Season 7[]
- Robert Englund
- Doug Drexler
- Mike Elizalde (Foundation)
- Michele Burke (Foundation)
- Clinton Collins, Jr.
Season 8[]
- Ve Neill (Foundation)
- Rick Baker
- Josh Hutcherson
- Jill Wagner (Foundation)
- Doug Jones
- Lois Burwell (Foundation)
- Mark Alan Miller
- The Coaches (Foundation)
- Darren Franich
- Todd McFarlane
- Don Mancini
Season 9[]
- Lois Burwell (Focus)
- Eryn Krueger Mekash (Foundation)
- Michael Westmore (Foundation)
- Jonathan Frakes (Spotlight)
- Robin Mathews (Foundation)
Season 10[]
- Paul Reubens (Spotlight)
- David Peterson (Spotlight)
- Gale Anne Hurd (Spotlight)
- Lance Henriksen (Foundation)
Season 11[]
- Natalie Berling (VP of Design at Mattel) and a focus group of Monster High superfans
- John Landis
- Paul W. S. Anderson
- Suzanne Todd
- Marcus Nispel
- Jeff Wolfe
Season 12[]
- Eryn Krueger Mekash
- Elizabeth Mitchell
- Travis Wall
- Cheyenne Jackson
- Neil Druckman
- Rick Baker